The Pilgrims' Cautionary Tale
Kate Zernike, writing for the New York Times, finds fault with what she calls “one common telling” of the story of the Pilgrims. That telling – she also calls it an “interpretation” of their experience – has it that they conducted a brief experiment in socialism. The problem for Zernike is that it’s not simply an interpretation or one common telling; it’s what no less an authority than William Bradford documents in Of Plymouth Plantation . Bradford, of course, was governor of Plymouth Colony for 30 years. It was not the Pilgrims who wanted a communal plantation; it was required by the terms of their agreement with the London Company that financed the colony. (He who pays the piper calls the tunes, as they say.) It did not go well. Here is Bradford in his own words: “They began to consider how to raise more corn, and obtain a better crop than they had done, so that they might not continue to endure the misery of want. At length after much debate, the Governor